Contents
Keywords and keyword rankings are somewhat useless nowadays. The tools we’ve relied on for 10-20 years can’t be trusted anymore, and we’re having to adapt. We’re seeing it in our own client data, where the tools miss most of the searches our clients actually appear for.
So, do keywords matter at all? Only as one input. What matters more now is logic: deciding what you want to be known for, and creating quality content around it, regardless of what Ahrefs says. In 2027, that’s how we decide what to create.
Below, we share what our data shows, and how we make that call instead.
Are keywords still relevant in SEO?
For most of SEO’s history, the answer was simple: yes. Keyword research was the starting point for deciding what to create, and search volumes were much more reliable. They told you three useful things:
- How many people were searching for a topic
- The words they actually used
- Which pages were worth creating first
That’s why keywords have been so important for SEO. They turned a guess into a plan.
But that only works if the data is right. Today, the numbers we used to decide what to create can no longer be trusted. Rankings go missing, volumes are estimates, and niche searches barely show up at all.
So, are keywords still relevant in SEO? As a signal, yes. But as the thing that decides your content plan? Not anymore. Here’s why.
Keyword tools are getting it wrong
Ahrefs is the market-leading SEO tool, and Semrush is a close second. We use both (here’s how they compare). But for keyword tracking, we’re finding them almost completely useless.
Even Ahrefs says its search volume “is always an estimation”, and that its figures are roughly accurate for only 60% of keywords when compared with Search Console data. So if you’ve ever wondered how accurate Semrush, Ahrefs and similar tools really are, the answer is: less than you’d think.
What our charity client’s data shows
One of our clients is a UK-based charity. In our keyword research, Ahrefs and Semrush told us the site had almost no rankings at all.
So we checked manually. We opened an incognito window and set a VPN to the location we wanted to search from. Then we searched each term we wanted to rank for, plus a few variants of each. The site ranked in the top three for around 90% of the terms we were tracking. They’re super niche, so the tools simply weren’t picking them up.
Google Search Console tells the same story. Over 90 days, the site appeared for 3,949 UK search queries, and Ahrefs showed just 46. Search Console recorded 680 top-three rankings, and Ahrefs showed 20.
To be fair, most of those queries are tiny. Only 53 of the 680 had 10 or more impressions. But that’s the point: niche searches are real, and the tools can’t see them.
3,949
UK search queries our charity client appears for in Google Search Console (90 days)
46
UK keywords Ahrefs shows for the same site
680 vs 20
Top-3 rankings: Search Console vs Ahrefs
What to do with low search volume keywords
So, what do you do with low search volume keywords? Use pure logic. Rather than looking at keyword volumes, ask one question: Is this what we want to be known for?
If the answer is yes, create the content, no matter how niche the topic is. Zero search volume keywords aren’t a reason to stay away, for two reasons:
- The data isn’t there yet. New and emerging industries don’t have much search data, but they will soon. Publishing now means you’re already there when demand catches up.
- Niche converts. The more specific a search is, the more likely the person searching is ready to buy.
And it’s never been easier to create and publish content. But if it’s still difficult for you, that’s where Buried comes in. It’s what we’re experts in: finding ways to deploy high-quality content efficiently, so you can capture these niche searches.
We’ve tested this on our own site. Here’s what happened.
How our Shopify service pages and location pages proved the keyword tools wrong
We’re experts in Shopify, and we’ve got a really nice Shopify client base. So creating Shopify service pages was an obvious move for us.
The keyword tools disagreed. According to Ahrefs, “shopify geo agency” has next to no search volume, and “shopify ai search optimisation” has none. Going by volume alone, there was no point, because apparently nobody was searching for it.
We created the pages anyway. Within a week of publishing them, two Shopify-specific leads came through, and both were really high-value.
Location pages did the same
We did a similar exercise with location pages. “GEO agency Dublin” shows zero UK searches in Ahrefs, and searches like “GEO agency Bristol” and “GEO agency Birmingham” have next to none. But they’re places we want to be known in.
Then a Shopify store in Dublin came to us, because we’d created our location pages and Shopify pages. That’s two sets of pages the tools said nobody was looking for, and three new leads came from them. That’s why we no longer let search volume decide what we create.
“If it’s something you want to be known for, then you need to create content around it, no matter how niche it is.”
Will Tombs, Founder, Buried
Keywords or prompts: Which matters more now?
So, keywords vs prompts: which should you focus on? We don’t think it’s a case of one over the other. What matters more is logic.
Both are unreliable, for different reasons:
- Keywords: Google has made changes that stop SEO tools from seeing where businesses really rank, so the data they show is incomplete.
- Prompts: The volumes behind prompt research just aren’t there yet. Google shares some data on keywords, but none on prompts. And what LLMs do share about prompts is still a complete black box.
So, the best approach to keyword research in the age of AI is a mix of both, plus logic. Use keyword data and prompt research as a guide. Then ask yourself: What’s important for us to be visible for? Finally, create quality content around that topic.
But what do you think? We’d love to hear.
What this means for SEOs
The tools we’ve relied on for 10-20 years can’t give us the full picture anymore. So we’re having to adapt and come up with much better solutions: Checking rankings manually, using Search Console to see real queries, and applying logic to decide what we create.
That’s a big change for SEOs, but it’s a good one.
For years, a lot of SEO meant going through and ticking boring boxes. Now, we get to think like marketers instead. Rather than chasing the biggest search volumes, we can focus on what our clients actually want to be known for, and create content that gets them there.
So, do keywords matter? A little. What you want to be known for matters a lot more.
Frequently asked questions about keywords
Is keyword research still worth doing?
Yes, but only as a starting point. Keyword data can still show you the topics people search for and the words they use. Just don’t let search volumes decide what you create, because the tools miss a lot. Use keyword data alongside prompt research, then apply marketing logic: Is this what you want to be known for? If it is, create the content anyway.
Should you still track keyword rankings?
You can, but don’t rely on keyword tools alone. Their data is estimated, and they often miss real rankings, especially for niche terms. Google Search Console is more reliable, because it shows the actual queries your site appears for. For the terms that matter most, check manually: search in an incognito window with a VPN set to the right location, and try a few variations of each term.
How do you measure AI search success without keyword rankings?
Focus on the results that matter to the business: Leads, enquiries and sales. Track how often AI answers mention or cite your brand for the prompts that matter to you, using a GEO tool. Then check AI referral traffic in your analytics. Most accurate of all, ask new customers how they found you, whether through a tick box on your forms or a question on the first sales call.
Should you target zero search volume keywords?
Yes, if it’s what you want to be known for. Zero search volume keywords are often niche, and the more niche a search is, the more likely it is to convert. Our Shopify service pages targeted terms with almost no search volume, yet they brought in two high-value leads within a week of publishing. In new and emerging industries, the volume often just hasn’t caught up yet.
Speak to an AI search expert
Not sure where organic search fits in your strategy? Tell us your goals and we will map the opportunity and the right level of focus.
Book a callAbout the author
Will Tombs
Founder, Buried
Will Tombs is the Founder of Buried. He’s an award-winning growth marketing specialist and expert in SEO and GEO. With over 12 years’ experience in industry, Will has led digital strategy for: Startups that have gone on to be acquired, international enterprise retailers, and his own e-commerce businesses.